California ban on soda taxes worries health experts

AP

Print Article

California ban on soda taxes worries health expert

By AMERICAN HEART ASSOCIATION NEWS

California’s new law banning taxes on sugary drinks in the nation’s most populated state handed the beverage industry a major victory.

Health advocates, however, say it’s a major defeat for the public’s well-being.

They’re already looking into options to repeal the law that passed Thursday after a swift and dramatic political fight. Experts worry the law puts millions of people at higher risk for obesity, diabetes and other major health problems linked to sugary drinks. When soda, sports drinks and other sugar-packed beverages are more expensive, people drink fewer of them, tax supporters say.

The American Cancer Society, American Diabetes Association, American Heart Association and about 20 other groups issued a joint statement earlier this week opposing the measure.

“This is one of the worst pieces of legislation I have seen in more than 30 years spent fighting for better health for kids and families,” American Heart Association CEO Nancy Brown said in a news release.

The law forbids new local taxes on sugary drinks for the next 12 years. And while the soda industry is expected to try to duplicate its triumph elsewhere, one public policy expert warned that what happened in California might actually backfire in other states.

The legislation was part of a last-minute political deal to stop a different tax initiative that the beverage industry helped place on California’s November ballot. That measure would have prevented local communities from raising any kind of tax without first getting two-thirds “supermajority” approval from voters.

The beverage industry withdrew that initiative from the ballot after California Gov. Jerry Brown signed the local-tax moratorium into law. The Sacramento Bee  reported this week that Brown met with top soda industry officials weeks before signing the bill.

The American Beverage Association, which poured tens of millions of dollars into anti-soda tax efforts in California and elsewhere, declined to comment beyond issuing a statement that said its legislation is helping local communities. “Our aim is to help working families by preventing unfair increases in their grocery bills,” the statement said.

California joins Arizona and Michigan as states with laws blocking local governments from passing sugary drink taxes. In Oregon, voters will decide the issue in November.

The California law represents a reversal for a state that boasted four cities, including the nation’s first, to have passed a sugary drink tax. Berkeley, San Francisco, Oakland and Albany each impose a one cent-per-ounce levy on sugary beverages, which have been linked to obesity, diabetes, stroke, heart disease and tooth decay. The new law will not affect any of the taxes already in place.

"This is a tragic day for both public health and democracy," said Dr. John Maa, a general surgeon and president of the San Francisco Marin Medical Society.

Healthcare costs related to treating chronic conditions worsened by drinking sugary drinks have taken “an enormous toll on communities,” Maa said.

“To do something as shortsighted as banning soda taxes for an entire decade without understanding the science and economic implications is an error, a dreadful error,” he said.

The taxes have proven to be effective, Maa said. He pointed to a study that found purchases of sugary drinks in Berkeley dropped 10 percent in its first year of the tax, while sales of bottled water increased nearly 16 percent.

“People see the advertisements, they learn about obesity, diabetes and tooth decay, and then make a conscious decision,” Maa said. “Even in areas where a soda tax doesn't pass, the campaign educates people.”

Outside California, Philadelphia, Seattle and Boulder, Colorado, also have sugary drink taxes. They’re also being considered in other jurisdictions. That’s partly why the beverage industry has started funding efforts at the state capitol level rather than the local level.

“It’s not surprising that the industry will have its periodic victories because they’re spending tens of millions of dollars to fight taxes, compared to very little money for the public health community,” said Kelly Brownell, dean of the Sanford School of Public Policy at Duke University.

Because the science linking sugary beverage consumption to negative health outcomes is “rock solid,” Brownell said California’s action may prompt other state legislatures to propose statewide excise taxes on sugary drinks.

“So far, the only taxes have been at the city level, at least in the U.S., but there are places where they’re countrywide,” he said, noting Mexico, France and the United Kingdom are among roughly 25 countries and territories with national taxes.

“The science is so clear that taxes have established benefits. I wouldn’t be surprised if some other states don’t start to think about passing taxes statewide, rather than just leave it up to the cities.”

If you have questions or comments about this story, please email  editor@heart.org.

Print Article

Read More Food and Health

Immigrant Families Placed In Detention Centers Face Health Care Challenges

AP

July 02, 2018 at 11:57 am | The White House’s plan to indefinitely detain immigrant families together threatens the care of young children, experts worry, by placing them with an agency with little experience in handling such c...

Comments

Read More

A Baby Was Treated With A Nap And A Bottle Of Formula. The Bill Was $18,000.

AP

July 02, 2018 at 12:50 pm | On the first morning of Jang Yeo Im’s vacation to San Francisco in 2016, her 8-month-old son, Park Jeong Whan, fell off the bed in the family’s hotel room and hit his head. There was no blood, bu...

Comments

Read More

Independence Day food safety tips

AP

July 02, 2018 at 5:00 am | Independence Day is almost here again! It is a day for our nation to pause to appreciate and celebrate our freedom. Fourth of July celebrations often include an outdoor picnic with lots of tasty trea...

Comments

Read More

Flu lasts for more than an hour in air and on surfaces – why cleaning can really help

AP

July 02, 2018 at 5:00 am | (The Conversation is an independent and nonprofit source of news, analysis and commentary from academic experts.) Seema Lakdawala, University of Pittsburgh and Linsey Marr, Virg...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 664-8176
215 N. Second St
Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814

©2018 The Coeur d'Alene Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X