Brugger: Let's talk alternative health care

AP

Print Article

I have to hand it to the governor and the less libertarian-leaning of the Idaho Republicans. They have proposed an answer to Idahoís population who want less expensive health insurance. Not only that, it seems that Idaho insurance companies may access out-of-state markets since there have been rumors that the new tax bill will allow buying insurance across state lines.

While I want to give credit where credit is due, I do not believe that the less expensive, less comprehensive, policies enhance public health. They also leave insureds exposed to significant costs not covered by insurance. Economics aside, I am especially concerned about peopleís access to best practices in health care. When I consider public policy, I look for sufficiency first, but I am mindful that tax money should not buy more than is needed.

Sufficient health care means medical, dental and vision care from birth to death. It includes regular checkups, inoculations, testing, and disease intervention at the earliest possible moment. I include dental because disease in the teeth and surrounding gums can attack other parts of the body, notably the heart, and can significantly weaken overall wellness. Vision affects the ability to be mobile and to access information. Mobility is crucial to exercise which, in turn, is crucial to the prevention of a plethora of diseases. One could argue that hearing is also part of the mix.

The Affordable Care Act began to bend the cost curve of medical care in the United States in a more sustainable direction because of the comprehensive medical care that was available to many who did not have it before. Eventually, it will make the cost of Medicare less expensive because individuals arenít arriving at age 65 having postponed needed care until Medicare coverage. If the ACA had been implemented as designed or, better yet, tweaked as appropriate, insurance rates for everyone would have stopped their relentless rise and even fallen somewhat.

In my perspective the one great problem with the ACA was that it never became universal. There were people in the population who refused to participate on ideological grounds. There were people who could not afford to buy insurance and were not covered by a public program. Additionally, there were people who did not or would not take advantage of the benefit of having annual physicals or going to have something checked out before it became more serious.

The economic and social impact of a more effective health care system would be enormous in terms of quality of life as well as the costs of social welfare. From successful childbirth to robust school children to fewer disabled adults to fewer frail elderly, the benefit of comprehensive health care is probably best seen in the Scandinavian countries. Enhanced by good public health policies advanced by the surgeon general and the CDC, we can have it all.

I suspect that my arguments will fall on deaf ears to those individuals whose outlook favors no market or social regulation at all. A belief that itís every man for himself. That position goes against my personal moral beliefs. I have lived a fortunate life, and I want similar fortune for everyone possible. I want to live in a society where access to extraordinary medical care doesnít depend on fundraisers initiated by caring friends. I want to live where disability is not caused by diabetes or heart disease or pain that is untreated until the individual is covered by Medicaid.

Less expensive policies are better than nothing. They are very profitable because they depend on three things: Few people will meet the coverage thresholds, people are healthy when they sign up, and people will drop them when times are tough if they are healthy and itís a safe bet they wonít need them. When I was selling insurance, I didnít want to bother with that market, and still wouldnít. Still, in these uncertain times, I have to agree that some health insurance is better than nothing. We can, however, do better.

Print Article

Read More Food and Health

Snake River H.S. to host free health fair

AP

January 20, 2018 at 4:54 pm | Snake River High School and Idaho State University have teamed up to host the third annual community health fair. The health fair is from 6 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. Thursday at Snake River High School, ...

Comments

Read More

Guest column: Story Story Night comes to I.F.

AP

January 20, 2018 at 5:00 am | When I suggested Boiseís Story Story Night event should happen in Idaho Falls, it was because I was ready to make myself a more committed member of this community, writes Leanne Thurston. Slam po...

Comments

Read More

Guest column: Growing Idaho?s physician workforce

AP

January 20, 2018 at 5:00 am | Idaho desperately needs more doctors and so far the state isnít committing the funds to make that happen, writes Rex W. Force. Idaho currently ranks 49th for physicians per capita and the stronge...

Comments

Read More

Busy session ahead for Idaho representatives

AP

January 19, 2018 at 5:00 am | BOISE - Property managers gone bad, addiction recovery and tax breaks for disabled veterans are some of the issues north central Idaho representatives hope to address during the 2018 legislative sess...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 664-8176
215 N. Second St
Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814

©2018 The Coeur d'Alene Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X