Take health insurance off employers’ backs — they’ll gladly give up the tax credit


Print Article

Lori Shandro OŁten is one of five Treasure Valley experts the Idaho Statesmanís Business Insider magazine asked to describe how to repair our broken health-insurance system.

Lori Shandro OŁten is on the front line of the health insurance crisis. A former certified public accountant, she opened The Shandro Group, a small independent insurance agency, in 2005.

OŁten works with individuals who need to buy insurance on Your Health Idaho, the Idaho exchange. She also works with small-business owners who want to provide insurance for their employees.

Both of her client bases are stressed and stretched, she says. With mounting questions and concerns about Congressí inability to follow through on promises to repair or replace the Affordable Care Act, itís likely to get worse. In July, the four companies on the Idaho exchange proposed rate increases as much as 68 percent come January.

ďThis past Jan. 1, I wrote about 15 new policies for small employers who didnít offer it before, because all of their employees were in individual plans, but the premiums went up 30 percent,Ē she says. ďItís going to be worse this Jan. 1. The [Idaho] Department of Insurance told the companies to file their rates as though they were not going to get cost-share reduction monies that are part of the law.Ē

Q: How would you fix the Affordable Care Act?

Assuming the cost of health care isnít going to change? Well, there should be transparency in understanding where the real problems lie and in understanding what the real cost factors are.

If you took into account what our country already spends, what state and federal governments spend, what companies spend on the HR departments you need to figure out how to do it all, and the lost tax revenue from companies deducting what they pay for benefits, if you took all of that into account, we could afford to give everybody access to coverage.

Is that single payer?

Not really. Thatís a little bit how they do it in Germany, which is a multipayer system, and itís how it works with ACA if you get a tax credit.

If we could broaden that idea and re-evaluate and redistribute the money weíre already spending, we could provide everyone with a stipend and let them buy their own plan. It [the stipend] is based on the cost of the silver [midlevel] plan, but you can choose to buy a bronze [low-end] or gold [high-end] plan.

Itís so wrong that the people I work with either canít afford the coverage, or they canít afford to use it when they need to. Itís embarrassing that our country canít figure this out.

Why do you think that would work?

Most employers that I work with would rather not have to deal with providing health care. Theyíd rather run their tech company or printing business and buy new equipment. They donít want the deduction. They want someone else to provide that, and no one is.

Even if you had your open enrollment period and the employer brought in a consultant to help people make choices, that would be so much cheaper and more effective than the employer saying, ďIím going to choose these plans and spend all this money on it,Ē and theyíre not even sure itís what their employees want.

I wonder, if everyone had health care and didnít have to stress about it, how much bigger would the [gross domestic product] be? What if the average citizen didnít ... have to plan their lives around jobs because they provide benefits? What if they were free to start the company they always wanted instead of working for someone just for the benefits?

Whatís the bottom line?

We have to reduce health care costs. Insurance companies canít control the cost of health care, and no one is trying to do anything about it.

And I donít know what the incentive is for health care providers to govern themselves.

When has any pharmaceutical company or medical devices company said, ďYou know what? I donít need to make this much. Letís find a way to change things so we donít have to charge so much.Ē

Physicians should be paid for maintaining someoneís health, not for every service they provide.

People think hospitals are nonprofit. Wouldnít it be great if their way of reinvesting in the community could also reduce costs? Instead, they put the profits into facilities, property, landscaping and sound systems in surgery suites. They should figure out what they really need to provide the best health care and use their profits to subsidize the cost.

Dana Oland: 208-377-6442, @IDS_DanaOland

The views of all five experts will appear Sept. 20 in the print edition of Business Insider. Follow these links to the other four:

?†Dr. Ted Epperly, CEO of Family Medicine Residency of Idaho, argues that it is time to go to single-payer health insurance.

?†Dean Cameron, director of the Idaho Department of Insurance director, urges a return to pre-Obamacare plans and less federal regulation.

?†Charlene Maher, CEO of Blue Cross of Idaho, contends that regulation by Idaho instead of the federal government would solve health insurance woes.

?†John Rusche, a Democratic former state legislator, former insurance executive and a retired physician, argues that everyone must participate in health insurance, and insurers deserve more certainty.

Print Article

Read More Food and Health

Trumpís Deadline On ĎDreamersí Reverberates Through Health Industries


September 18, 2017 at 5:00 am | Karla Ornelas said she has ďalways had the idea of being a doctor, Iíve never seen myself doing anything else.Ē The third-year pre-medical student at the University of California-Davis said she plans...


Read More

Without Price Breaks, Rural Hospitals Struggle To Stock Costly, Lifesaving Drugs


September 18, 2017 at 5:00 am | MOUNTAIN VIEW, Ark. ó Hospital pharmacist Mandy Langston remembers when Lulabelle Berry arrived at Stone County Medical Centerís emergency department last year. Berry couldnít talk. Her face was ...


Read More

Southwest Idaho Treatment Center in Nampa in a state of transition


September 18, 2017 at 4:00 pm | NAMPA ó Legislation passed this year in the Idaho Legislature will create a new secure wing onto the Southwest Idaho Treatment Center in Nampa. For 100 years, the facility has served people with ...


Read More

Can spraying bacteria in your face actually have health benefits?


September 18, 2017 at 5:00 am | By AMERICAN HEART ASSOCIATION NEWS Spraying bacteria in your face for health reasons sounds like something straight out of a late-night TV commercial. It sounds even stranger when you con...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 664-8176
215 N. Second St
Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814

©2017 The Coeur d'Alene Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy